At the Philadelphia Film Society in Philadelphia, PA, I saw a 4K restoration of Manhunter, a 1986 crime thriller written and directed by Michael Mann, based on the 1981 novel Red Dragon by Thomas Harris. The film starred William Petersen as Will Graham, an FBI profiler who is hunting a serial killer named Francis Dollarhyde (Tom Noonan), otherwise known as the Tooth Fairy. The killer stalks families from a distance and mass murders them in their home, and Graham, having previously caught the serial killer and former psychiatrist Hannibal Lecter (Brian Cox) is taking on this job, trying to get inside of the mind of the killer to catch him, and it is triggering his mental health issues and psychosis. He also has to meet with Lecter, who is being held in a high-security prison, to get his insight on the killer's mind and face his demons, as Lecter tried to kill him years earlier.
I really liked this film a lot. It's very moody with a synth score by Michel Rubini and The Reds, and as the film came out at the time Miami Vice was on, which Mann created, it echoes the same atmospheric style, like with Graham's Florida beach home and the musical montages with rock and pop songs, and big electric guitar solos heightening the drama.
I liked that a lot of the film was focusing on the forensics of catching the killer, like analyzing a note written by the Tooth Fairy on toilet paper, seeing that it was broken up into two parts and analyzing the ink and paper under infrared light to figure it out, with Graham and his FBI superior Jack Crawford (Dennis Farina)'s body language ready to pounce and run to the next place to get the results, having a short window of time where the evidence is usable. It brought a lot of suspense to the scenes, while also adding it 1980s-era forensic science to the film that made it more fascinating in a nerdy way.
The casting is excellent. When I initially saw some of this film, William Petersen's character made me feel anxious and uncomfortable, and I stopped watching, but this time around, I stuck with it, and the film's story about him recovering from a mental breakdown and trying to protect his sanity made a lot more sense on why he gets so agitated and tries to think like a killer to catch one. The scene in which he speaks with his son while grocery shopping about why he had mental health issues after Lecter attacked him was really well-acted, and it seemed rare to see a depiction of men talking about their mental problems at that time.
Dennis Farina was a lot of fun to watch with his nasal Chicago accent and bringing in his background as a former police detective to the role (he had worked as a police consultant to Michael Mann for his film Thief and appeared in his projects). Stephen Lang was excellent as an annoying tabloid reporter who meets a tragic end, and Joan Allen was really convincing as a blind woman, and her scene where she strokes and pets a sedated large tiger was gorgeous to watch.
Brian Cox was fantastic as Hannibal Lecter, who is only in a few scenes of the film, but is intelligent and funny and manipulative, and finds ways to antagonize Graham under guises of politeness. And Tom Noonan was chilling as the Tooth Fairy, a tall, lanky figure who cannot get emotionally close to anyone. The sequence of the film from his perspective, where Joan Allen's character seduces him and he doesn't know how to handle a woman being attracted to him was really interesting, and how he feels like he could be normal with a woman before inevitably reverting back to his serial killer ways.
I'm glad I watched this film again and understood it much better, it's a really fantastic crime thriller of the 1980s, and started off the film and TV franchise of the Hannibal Lecter series that would go on for decades.