On Criterion, I watched Who Killed Teddy Bear?, a 1965 crime thriller directed by Joseph Cates and co-written by comic book writer Arnold Drake and Leon Tokatyan. The film stars Juliet Prowse as Norah Dain, a nightclub DJ and aspiring actress who lives in Manhattan, and keeps getting obscene phone calls from a creepy guy claiming to be watching her. She is disgusted and calls him out for being a pervert. She finds a decapitated teddy bear in her apartment, and calls the cops. The police detective, Lt. Dave Madden (Jan Murray) investigates her case, and takes a personal interest in Norah. His wife was raped and murdered, and he openly listens to audio recordings of his interviews with Norah and other women talking about obscene phone callers, with his ten-year old daughter in bed listening to the recordings. He is a red herring, as his suspicious behavior makes Norah uncomfortable and worrying that he may be the caller, but he isn't.
The reveal of the caller happens a little earlier than I would've liked, but I still found the film interesting as a depiction of Times Square as a sleazy place in the mid-1960s. Norah works as a DJ at a club, where there are creative camera angles from below of people dancing and doing shimmys and hip twists and very 1960s dance moves.
The movie explores a lot of mature themes like voyeurism, pornography, incest, and lesbianism, and feels more like a B-movie getting out from under the censorship of the Hayes Code.
I liked Juliet Prowse's performance as Norah, where the film gives her agency as a woman who doesn't want the obscene phone calls to stop her from living her life as a DJ and actress, to be an independent young woman in New York City. Prowse's performance made her feel more like a person and less like a movie stock character.
Sal Mineo was great in a supporting role as Lawrence, a waiter at the club who lives with his sister, Edie (Margot Bennett), who is 19 but talks like a child due to a brain injury from a childhood accident. Lawrence struggles with taking care of his sister and dealing with his own traumatic issues, and Mineo gave a great performance as a guy who focuses on making himself look fit and handsome on the outside, but is wrestling demons with his mental health on the inside.
Elaine Stritch was fun in a supporting role as Marian, a manager at the club where Norah works, and she cares about Norah's safety as a young woman being stalked. There's a heartbreaking scene where Marian is trying to comfort Norah, but Norah mistakes it as Marian making a lesbian pass at her, and is horrified. Marian doesn't fully understand why Norah is angry, but is annoyed that she misinterpreted her act of friendship for something she found devious. It's a great scene that Stritch played excellently.
I really liked this weird, lurid little movie, and the b/w cinematography by Joseph C. Brun was gorgeous.






















