At the Village East Cinema in Manhattan, I saw Obsession, a 2025 supernatural psychological horror film written and directed by Curry Barker. The film stars Michael Johnston as Bear, a young man in his early twenties who works at a music store with his friends Ian (Cooper Tomlinson), Sarah (Megan Lawless), and Nikki (Inde Navarette). Bear has a crush on Nikki, but is too nervous to confess his feelings to her, and Ian wants him to just get it over with and ask her, but not during their weekly bar trivia night, as to not spoil the fun. Bear comes home to find that his cat Sandy has died after accidentally consuming Bear's oxycodone pills. The next day, he shops for a gift for Nikki because she lost her crystal necklace, and he goes to a crystal shop, but instead of getting a crystal, he finds a novelty toy called "One Wish Willow," where the user can make one wish and break a plastic log in half.
Later that night, after bar trivia, Bear drives Nikki home, who is asking him if he likes Sarah, hinting that Sarah likes him. Bear completely whiffs the chance to confess his feelings, denying it when Nikki directly asks if he likes her, and as she is at the front door of his house, Bear in his car goes, "I wish Nikki loved me more than anyone else in the world," and snaps the willow log. Suddenly, Nikki stops before going into the house, then runs back to Bear in his car, and her behavior is erratic, switching between wanting him to come inside and then screaming, and then brushing off her own behavior as "weird." Bear is confused by Nikki's behavior, but comes in, and she keeps switching between trying to seduce him and having screaming fits. Bear doesn't understand any of this, and despite his own hesitations, he is flattered when Nikki is attracted to him, and against his better judgment, takes advantage of the situation, and they become a couple, with Nikki being overly possessive and jealous, manipulating him with her mood swings.
This movie could be taken in different ways, how it is about an unhealthy, codependent relationship, where the monster that has taken over Nikki (it is implied that the real Nikki's consciousness is trapped in some kind of hell while the "loving girlfriend" persona takes over, with large, forced smiles that she holds for an uncomfortable amount of time) is the abuser, taking advantage of Bear's attraction to her by keeping him close to her and acting out in random violence of hurting herself or others. But that it can be seen as Bear having unwittingly taken away Nikki's free will, and rather than finding a way earlier to undo the spell or fix things, he lets it go on because he is happy that his crush is so into him and his fantasy has become a reality. Nikki may be the violent one causing mayhem, but Bear is the one who started this by being unable to face rejection or get out of his arrested development of acting like a teenager when he is past 21 years old.
The movie is very effective with silhouettes and shadows, often hiding Nikki's face, or the brief times when the real Nikki will get control of her body to speak her own words or ask for help before the monster shuts her down again.
The two leads are fantastic in the film. Michael Johnston takes a character that can be sympathetic at first as a lovelorn loser who is pining after his crush, unaware that his other female friend is into him, and seems emotionally stunted and needs to grow up more. But then he becomes more selfish in taking advantage of the situation, and though his idle wish doesn't deserve such punishment, when the real Nikki reaches out to him for help, he still can only think of his own desires and not her feelings.
Inde Navarette is in a star-making turn with this performance. Director Curry Barker had her study performances from Betty Gabriel in Get Out, Toni Collette in Hereditary, and Mia Goth in Pearl to develop the character of Nikki, and there are elements from those roles, like Betty Gabriel's performance as a woman whose body is possessed and whose soul is in the Sunken Place, only able to briefly reach out with her real life briefly, and Mia Goth's performance as a manic woman who tries to act "normal" but, in the finale, greets her horrified husband with an unsettling wide smile throughout the ending credits. Navarette switches between voices and personas quickly; saying "no" several times in one scene with different rising intonations; and her physical performance is raw and emotionally taxing. The film helps with showing Nikki before the transformation, as a regular person, making it more tragic when her body and mind is stolen by this demon because of Bear's unrequited crush.
The movie is also darkly funny. It's meant to be grim, but there are several moments that are funny, like Nikki's intense frowny face; the reaction from a crystal shop employee saying that people come back to complain about the wishes they got and Bear not understanding the risk he's taking; the response from the One Wish Willow customer service representative that Bear calls to try to cancel the wish; and another attempt to fix the wish that goes horribly wrong.
I really liked this movie. I kept forgetting the characters were young adults because they acted like teenagers, and it did speak a lot to their own immaturity and limited life experiences when trying to handle adult situations. I'm glad this movie ended up becoming a sleeper hit, it's well-deserved.

























